# Private Aided Management Schools – Filling up of aided pots in pursuance of interim orders passed by the Hon’ble High Court in IA No.1 of 2018 in WP.No.1041/2018 – Orders

- Link: https://amaravathiteacher.com/private-aided-management-schools-filling-up-of-aided-pots-in-pursuance-of-interim-orders-passed-by-the-honble-high-court-in-ia-no-1-of-2018-in-wp-no-1041-2018-orders/
- Published: 2021-06-14T19:08:25+05:30
- Author: Venkat

## Private Aided Management Schools – Fillingup of aided pots in pursuance of interim orders passed by the Hon’ble High Court in IA No.1 of 2018 in WP.No.1041/2018 – Orders G.O.MS.No. 37

G.O.MS.No. 37  Dated: 14-06-2021

1. G.O.Ms.No.1, Education (PS.2) Department, dt:01.01.1994.
 2. Interim orders issued
in IA No.1 of 2018 in WP.1041 of 2018 dated 29-2-2020 of the Hon`ble High Court 
of Andhra Pradesh. 3. Letter.No.ESE02-17/544/2020-PS1- CSE, dated. 30-5-2021 of 
the Director of School Education, A.P, Ibrahimpatnam

ORDER: –
 In the Letter 3rd read above, the Director of School Education, Andhra
Pradesh has stated that the Private Recognized Aided School Management Association,
has approached the Hon’ble High Court by filing WP.No.1041 of 2018,challenging the
Memo.No.756924 /PS/ A2/ 2017,Dated:12.09.2017 and consequential proceedings of the
DSE vide Rc.No.PS-I/2010, dated:12.09.2017 and the Proc.No. 90/PSI/ 2010-3,Dated:
20.07.2017,pursuant to the note dated:09.09.2017. 2. In the reference 2nd read above,
the Hon’ble High Court issued interim orders in I.A.No.1 of 2018 in W.P.No.1041 
of 2018 as extracted below: “Therefore, while suspending the Memo No. 756924 /PS/
A2/ 2017, Dated:12.09.2017 by the 1 st respondent and the consequential Memo in 
Rc.No.PS-1/2010, dated:12.09.2017 issued by the 2nd respondent, there shall be interim
direction to the respondents 1 to 5 to commence the process of filling the aided
posts vacant in the aided institutions in the State of Andhra Pradesh, pending disposal
of the writ petition.” 3. Earlier, challenging the ban Memo. No.12080/COSE/A2/2004-
4, Dated. 20.10.2004, on creation/ filling up of aided posts, WP.No.9503/2005 & 
batch of Writ Petitions filed and in pursuance of the orders of the Hon’ble courts,
Government have permitted all the District Education Officers/Regional Joint Directors
of School Education in the state of A.P to grant temporary permission to all the
Managements of Aided Schools covered in all court cases covered under the judgment
of High Court of A.P in W.P.No.9503 of 2005 and batch, dated 30.07.2013, subject
to outcome of W.Ps/W.As/SLPs etc., of any on certain conditions vide Memo.No.18836/
PS/A2/2010, dated.03.12.2016. 4. Government, vide G.O.Ms.No.40, School Education(
PS) Department, Dated 30.06.2017, have withdrawn above ban Memo.dt. 20.10.2004, 
duly according permission to the institutions covered in W.P.No.9503 of 2005 and
batch (78 petitioners Managements) for filling up of the aided posts on permanent
basis, vide Memo. No. 18836/PS/A2/2010-34, dated 30.06.2017.

5. Pursuant to the above orders, the C&DSE, vide
 Procgs.Rc.No.90/PS- I/2010-3,dated
20.07.2017, has issued certain guidelines, for filling up of posts in aided schools
covered under W.P.No.9503/2005 and batch, and accordingly, aided posts filled in(
17) schools of W.P.9503/2005 & batch cases and (12) schools of squarely covered 
cases. 6. Owing to the orders passed in WP.No.9503 of 2005 & batch, (316) petitioners
filed WPs, with a plea to extend the orders issued in 9503 and batch cases. The 
Hon`ble High Court issued orders extending the judgment issued in W.P.9503/2005 
and batch, to the (209) petitioner schools also. Subsequently, certain other aided
managements have also been approaching the Hon`ble High Court and getting similar
orders. 7. As per Rule 12 (1) of the G.O. 1st read above, the educational agency
shall appoint staff as per the staffing pattern prescribed by Government from time
to time. Government prescribed teacher pupil ratio 1:40 under Rule 10(12) of said
G.O., for according permission/ recognition to the private institutions and hence,
it has been taken into consideration to identify the need to fill up the aided vacancies.
8. In compliance to the norms prescribed under Right to Education Act, 2009 and 
the Rules issued in 2010, Government issued norms prescribing staffing pattern in
G.O.Ms. No. 40, Education (SE/PS–1) Department dated. 18-06-2013 for aided schools
specifically and ordered that if any teaching and non teaching posts are found surplus
the same be rationalized within the district among aided schools. But certain managements
have challenged the GO and the Hon`ble High Court issued interim orders on 13-08-
2013 in WP No.25319 of 2013 and in certain other similar W.Ps that “ the rationalization
may be proceeded in accordance with and that however there shall be an interim direction
not to finalize the rationalization until further orders.” and in another WP No.
25014/2013, the Hon’ble High Court passed orders on 27-08-2013, “that the G.O.Ms
No:40 Education dated: 18-06- 2013 does not apply to the petitioner’s institutions
i.e., Minority Institutions”. The said interim orders of the Hon`ble High Court 
are still in force. Hence the School Education Department could not go ahead with
the staffing pattern as prescribed by G.O.Ms. No. 40, Education (SE/PS–1) Department
dated. 18-06-2013. 9. Government after due consultation, have observed that promotions
of teachers can not undertake in Aided Institutions either in terms of G.O.Ms.No.
9, School Education (Ser.II) Department, Dated.23.1.2009 and G.O.Ms.No.11, School
Education (Ser.II) Department, dated 23-1-2009 or G.O.Ms.No.40, School Education(
SE.PS-I) Department, dated 18-06-2013, since the Hon`ble High Court, seized the 
matter, and also observed that rationalization can undertake in accordance with 
the G.O.Ms.No.40 dated 18-6-2013 but the same could not be finalized until further
orders. 10. Since, further action as per G.O. Ms.No.40, School Education Department,
Dated.18.6.2013 could not be taken up, the norms of Teacher-Pupil Ratio of 1:40 
as per Rule 10(12) of G.O.1st read above, is being followed to fix the staffing 
pattern to fill up the aided vacancies at present.

11. The private aided managements are under the impression that
 they have a right
to fill up all the vacant aided posts even though the enrolment is not commensurate
with the enrolment. The private aided managements are ascribing the poor enrolment
to the non filling up of the teachers posts and that they are requesting to fill
up the posts first so that they would be able to show better performance. While 
submitting the stand of the private aided managements, the Director of School Education
has brought it to the notice of the Government that, there is a consistent declining
trend in the admissions in aided schools, is noticed over a period of time. Whereas,
the enrolment is increasing in the Government run schools in the state and during
the academic year 2020-21, there is an overall increase of (5,26,484) children in
the government schools compared to previous year, i.e., 2019- 20 even though more
number of teaching posts are lying vacant in Government managed schools. The enrolment
in aided schools is decreasing even though the Government has been extending midday
meal, free textbooks, notebooks, uniform, shoes, school bags etc., to the children
studying in the aided schools and even though financial assistance @ Rs.15,000/-
is being extended to each unique mother of the children studying in the aided schools
under Jagananna Ammavodi scheme. The Director, School Education has collected all
the basic data of all the private aided schools in April, 2021 and after analysis
it is found that this declining trend is due to the overall poor performance of 
the aided institutions as most of them are not having proper infrastructure facilities.
12. It is not essential to fill up all the sanctioned vacant posts in the private
aided schools without reference to the existing enrolment. If posts are filled up
without reference to the need it would result in wastage of human and financial 
resource of the government. As per Article 3 of A.P. Financial Code, the expenditure
should not be prima facie more than the occasion demands. Every Government servant
is expected to exercise the same diligence and care in respect of all expenditure
from public moneys under his control as a person of ordinary prudence would exercise
in respect of the expenditure of his own money. If the Private Aided Management 
improves the enrollment in the school in future by improving their overall performance,
the management may approach the government through the competent authorities for
permission to fill up the sanctioned vacant posts from time to time. But seeking
permission to fill up all the sanctioned vacant posts irrespective of enrolment 
is not feasible for consideration. 13. As per Rule 12 (1) of the GO 1st read above,
the educational agency is permitted to fill up the posts as per the sanctioned staffing
pattern approved by government from time to time and this particular clause of ‘
from time to time’ is incorporated in the G.O. with the precise intention to regulate
the filling up of the posts based on need and enrolment from time to time. While
according permission to the educational agencies of the private aided managements
to fill up the posts, the norm of 1:40 as per Rule 10(12) of the G.O. 1st read above
has to be followed, since no further action can be proceeded as per GO.Ms.No.40,
School Education Department, Dated.18.6.2013 where the staffing pattern was prescribed
as per RTE norms.

14. The Division Bench of Hon’ble High Court of Andhra Pradesh in
 Writ Appeal No.
1578 of 2005 & batch and W.P.No.21793 of 2005 & batch, dated 29.12.2006 and the 
operative portion of judgment is extracted below: “ In view of the above conclusion,
we do not consider it necessary to adjudicate on the vires of G.O.Ms.No.103, dated
5-8-2005. However, we feel that it will be more prudent for the government to examine
the entire issue objectively and take corrective measures if it is found that the
norms are contrary to the provisions contained in Rule 10 (12) or 10 (17) of the
1993 Rules. In the result, the appeals are dismissed. The writ petitions filed by
the management of the private schools and others are allowed. Now, the management
of the private schools shall be free to appoint selected candidates and seek approval
of such appointments from the competent authority. The exercise of rationalization
undertaken in furtherance of interim order dated 31-10-2005 passed by this Court
and directions contained in letter dated 3-11-2005 issued by the Director of School
Education are quashed. However, it is made clear that this order shall not prevent
the competent authorities from undertaking fresh exercise for rationalization, which
may lead to declaration of certain teachers’ surplus and for absorption of such 
surplus teachers.” 15. The Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in WP(C) No. 95 of 2010
in its orders , dated 12.04.2012, while upholding constitutional validity of the
RTE Act 2009, has made the following observations: “ The State is also expected 
to first weed out those schools which are non performing or underperforming or non
compliance schools and upon closure of such schools, the students and teaching and
non teaching staff thereof should be transferred.., (Para 8 of the Judgment).” Needless
to observe that if there is inadequate response to the Government funded school,
it is but appropriate that either the divisions there of or the school itself be
closed and the students and staff of such schools be transferred.., (Para 8 of the
Judgment).” In our view even State Government must take opportunity to re organize
its financial outflow at the micro level by weeding out non performing or under 
performing or non compliance schools receiving grant–in–aid so as to ensure that
only such Government funded schools who fulfill norms and standards are allowed 
to continue(Para-8 of the Judgment).” 16. In pursuance of the orders of Hon’ble 
High Court in the reference 2nd read above and in the circumstances reported by 
the Director of School Education, in the reference 3rd read above, Government after
careful examination, hereby issue the following orders: a. The Director of School
Education, shall commence the process of

filling the vacant aided posts in all aided institutions by
 identifying the need
each school wise based on the enrolment of the school as on the last working day
of the academic year 2020- 21 (19-04-2021 for primary and upper primary schools 
and 30- 04-2021 for high schools) as reported by the managements in the child info
of the Unified District Information of School Education (UDISE+). Accordingly, the
Director of School Education shall issue order showing the need as per the TPR of
1:40 under Rule 10(12) of the G.O.1st read above, since there is no other norm presently
available for deciding the staffing pattern of private aided schools in the state.
b. Once the need is identified, the Director of School Education shall direct the
competent authorities viz., Regional Joint Directors of School Education in case
of high schools and District Education Officers in case of Primary and Upper Primary
schools to identify the surplus teachers as per rule 10(12), and to deploy them 
as per Rule (12)(3) (A) of G.O.Ms.No.1, Education dated 01- 01- 1994 into the vacant
sanctioned aided posts in the needy schools as per the need without exceeding to
the number of sanctioned aided posts and after completion of this exercise, to permit
the competent authorities to send proposal to the Government to accord permission
to issue clearance certificate as required under Rule 12(3)(A) of G.O.Ms.No.1, Education
dated. 1-1-1994 to take up recruitment if still need exists. c. Since, earlier the
Commissioner and the Director of School Education has permitted to fill up the posts
in certain managements covered under WP No 9503/2005 and batch in terms of G.O.Ms.
No.40 Education dated 30-6-2017 and as per the orders issued by Government in Memo.
No.18836/PS/ A2/ 2010-32 to 34, dated. 30-6-2017 and as per the orders issued in
CSE Procs.Rc.No.90/PS-1/2020-1 to 3, dated. 20-7-2017 without following the norm
of 1:40 and since the posts were already filled up, the Director of School Education
shall now identify if any excess posts were permitted to be filled up duly arriving
the need as per Rule 10(12) of G.O.Ms.No.1, Education dated. 01-01-1994 and adjust
them in the future vacancies in those schools. 17. The Director of School Education,
A.P, shall take further necessary action accordingly, in the matter, and furnish
a detailed report to the Government after completion of the above exercise, for 
taking further necessary action.

[DOWNLOAD COMPLETE G.O.MS.No. 37](https://drive.google.com/file/d/1YO5GbTz3iBgF2skkP-njKcaX7i80XjGN/view?usp=sharing)

### 󠀁[AP TEACHERS LATEST NEWS](https://amaravathiteacher.com/category/ap-teachers-latest-news/)󠁿

 *  [ NEW AP SSC Exam Fee Online Payment – AP SSC March 2027 Fee Due Dates ](https://amaravathiteacher.com/ap-ssc-exam-fee-online-payment/)
 *  [ NEW SA1 Question Papers 2026 PDF Download – 1st to 5th Classes | Telugu, English, Maths, EVS ](https://amaravathiteacher.com/sa1-question-papers-2026-1st-to-5th-classes/)
 *  [ AP DSC 2026 Notification PDF Download – 2721 Vacancies, Syllabus – Apply Online ](https://amaravathiteacher.com/ap-dsc-2026-notification-apply-online/)
 *  [ APPSC AEE Recruitment 2026 – 503 Assistant Executive Engineer Posts ](https://amaravathiteacher.com/appsc-aee-recruitment-2026-notification-503-posts/)
 *  [ AP Local Body Elections 2026 Remuneration Rates – GO 1086 | ఎన్నికల సిబ్బంది రెమ్యునరేషన్ ](https://amaravathiteacher.com/ap-local-body-election-remuneration-rates-2026-go-1086/)
 *  [ GVMC Teachers School Educational Subordinate Service Rules, 2026 G.O.Ms.No.40 ](https://amaravathiteacher.com/gvmc-teachers-school-educational-subordinate-service-rules-2026-g-o-ms-no-40/)
 *  [ Vijayawada Municipal Corporation Teachers School Educational Subordinate Service Rules 2026 GO No 39 ](https://amaravathiteacher.com/vijayawada-municipal-corporation-teachers-school-educational-subordinate-service-rules-2026-go-no-39/)
 *  [ AP Municipal Corporation Teachers Service Rules 2026 GO 38 ](https://amaravathiteacher.com/ap-municipal-corporation-teachers-service-rules-2026-go-38/)
 *  [ AP Municipal School Educational Subordinate Service Rules 2026, GO Ms 37 ](https://amaravathiteacher.com/ap-municipal-school-educational-subordinate-service-rules-2026-go-ms-37/)
 *  [ AP School Education (Govt) Subordinate Service Rules 2026 – G.O.Ms.No.35 ](https://amaravathiteacher.com/ap-school-education-govt-subordinate-service-rules-2026-g-o-ms-no-35/)

[View More ](https://amaravathiteacher.com/category/ap-teachers-latest-news/)

### 󠀁[TEACHERS SOFTWARES](https://amaravathiteacher.com/category/teachers-softwares/)󠁿

 *  [ SMC Elections 2026 Notification Voters List Download ](https://amaravathiteacher.com/smc-elections-2026-notification-voters-list-download/)
 *  [ Income Tax Online Calculator FY 2026-27 ](https://amaravathiteacher.com/income-tax-online-calculator-fy-2026-27/)
 *  [ Student id Card Download ](https://amaravathiteacher.com/student-id-card-download/)
 *  [ AP DA Arrears Calculator 2026 ](https://amaravathiteacher.com/ap-da-arrears-calculator-2026/)
 *  [ AP New DA Salary Calculator ](https://amaravathiteacher.com/ap-new-da-salary-calculator/)
 *  [ AP EHS Hospitals List ](https://amaravathiteacher.com/ap-ehs-hospitals-list/)
 *  [ AP Teachers ID Card Download ](https://amaravathiteacher.com/ap-teachers-id-card-download/)
 *  [ Pdf Compressor Online ](https://amaravathiteacher.com/pdf-compressor-online/)
 *  [ Online image compressor ](https://amaravathiteacher.com/online-image-compressor/)
 *  [ AP Medical Reimbursement Proposal Software ](https://amaravathiteacher.com/ap-medical-reimbursement-proposal-software/)

[View More ](https://amaravathiteacher.com/category/teachers-softwares/)